Theoretical and practical bases of religious expertise in the Republic of Kazakhstan
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26577//EJRS.2023.v36.i4.r2Keywords:
religious expertise, scientific neutrality, religious activity, freedom of religion, religious extremismAbstract
The article deals with the main theoretical issues and functional mechanisms of the concept of religious expertise. To analyze this issue, the main scientific conclusions about the concept, goals and scientific and methodological foundations of religious expertise in international practice were differentiated. The limited number of scientific articles and research papers on this topic in domestic research determines the relevance of the identified problem and the need to systematize this area. Today, in the Republic of Kazakhstan, the field of religious studies expertise is one of the new directions. This area, implemented in the country for more than ten years, is a public service for legal entities and individuals. The practical aspects of the implementation of religious studies expertise are determined by the state within the framework of legislation in the field of religion. However, at the domestic level, it is necessary to solve the problem of determining the theoretical and conceptual categories of religious studies expertise, systematizing the main scientific methods. Since, in the course of studying foreign and domestic experience, it was found that the methodology for conducting religious expertise has not been developed at a sufficient level.
References
Әдебиеттер
Арыстанбекұлы Н. (2022) Қазақстан Республикасында дінтанулық сараптама жүргізудің тағылымдық мән-маңызы, Қазақстан Республикасы Ұлттық ғылым академиясының Хабаршысы, 3 (397). – Алматы. – 20.
Әбдірәсілқызы А. (2012) Дінтану сараптамасы: міндеттер мен мәселелер. [Электронды ресурс]. - URL: https://abai.kz/post/14930 (жүгіну күні: 18.05.2023);
Герасименко Ю.В. & Ваврух В.В. (2014) Религиоведческая экспертиза: проблемы и пути их решения // Научный вестник Омской академии МВД России № 4 (55). – М. –75.
Забияко А.П., (2019) Религиоведение как строгая наука / Философия, Религия, Наука №3 (11). – М. – 225.
Загребина И.В., Пчелинцев А.В.,Элбакян Е.С. (2017) Религиоведческая экспертиза. Учебник для бакалавриата и магистратуры, – М.: Юрайт. – 449.
Загребина И.В., Пчелинцев А.В.,Элбакян Е.С. (2021) Практика религиоведческой экспертизы, – М.: Юрайт. – 453.
Қазақстан Республикасы Ақпарат және қоғамдық даму министрлігі, Дін істері комитетінің ресми сайты (2023) [Электронды ресурс]. – URL: https://www.gov.kz/memleket/entities/din/activities/879?lang=kk&parentId=141 (жүгіну күні: 15.05.2023ж.)
Мырзаев Б.А. (2016) Дінтану сараптамасы жат идеологиялардың алдын алу сүзгісі ретінде [Электронды ресурс]. – URL:https://www.inform.kz/kz/dintanu-saraptamasy-zhat-ideologiyalardyn-aldyn-alu-suzgisi-retinde_a2928426 (жүгіну күні: 5.05.2023ж).
Ожегов С.И. (2018) Толковый словарь русского языка. Под редакцией проф. Л.И.Скворцова. – М.: «ООО «Издательство Мир и Образование». – 1376.
Петрова К.Ю. Орлов М.О. (2017) Религиоведческая экспертиза: типология, методология, проблемы / Аспирантский вестник Поволжья -Т XVII. №3-4. - 84
Посольство и консульство США в Казахстане (2023) [Электронды ресурс]. – URL: https://kz.usembassy.gov/ru/ru-2021-report-on-international-religious-freedom-kazakhstan-2/ (жүгіну күні: 25.05.2023ж)
Пчелинцев А.В. (2009) Экспертиза по «божественным делам»: инквизация или гарантия свободы религии / Религия и право. №3. – 64.
Разуваев А.А. (2006) Экспертиза как средство повышения эффективности процесса правореализации (вопросы теории и практики): автореф.дис.канд.юрид.наук. 12.00.01 / - Саратов. – 229
Россинская Е.Р. (2005) Судебная экспертиза в гражданском, арбитражном, административном и уголовном процессе / - М.: «Норма». – 656.
Тулеметова Г. (2022) Вопросы формирования понятийного аппарата религиоведческой экспертизы. Oriental studies 2022, №3. – 192.
Чернышкова З.Е., Иванова Е.В., Кузнецова О.В. (2017) Религиоведческая экспертиза: анализ действий, направленных на оскорбление религиозных чувств верующих // Исторические, философские, политические и юридические науки, культурология и искусствоведение. Вопросы теории и практики Тамбов: Грамота, № 3(77): в 2-х ч. Ч. 2. - 2012.
Элбакян Е.С. (2012) Научность религиоведческой экспертизы: возможность и необходимость // Новые вызовы свободы совести в современной России / под ред.Е.С.Элбакян. -М.: Древо жизни. – 164.
References
Abdіrasіlqyzy A. (2012) Dіntanu saraptamasy: mіndetter men maseleler. [Religious expertise tasks and problems]. - URL: https://abai.kz/post/14930 (date of the application: 18.05.2023) (in Kazakh)
Arystanbekuly N. (2022) Qazaqstan Respublikasynda dіntanulyq saraptama zhүrgіzudіn tagylymdyq man-manyzy [Religious expertise in the Republic of Kazakhstan educational value of driving], Qazaqstan Respublikasy Ulttyq gylym akademijasynyn Habarshysy, 3 (397), 20 (in Kazakh)
Chernyshkova Z.E., Ivanova E.V., Kuznecova O.V. (2017) Religiovedcheskaya e'kspertiza: analiz dejstvij, napravlennyx na oskorblenie religioznyx chuvstv veruyushhix [Religious Expertise: Analysis of Actions Aimed at Offending the Religious Feelings of Believers] // Istoricheskie, filosofskie, politicheskie i yuridicheskie nauki, kul'turologiya i iskusstvovedenie. Voprosy teorii i praktiki Tambov: Gramota, № 3(77): v 2-ch. Ch. 2. - 2012
E'lbakyan E.S. (2012) Nauchnost' religiovedcheskoj e'kspertizy: vozmozhnost' i neobxodimost' [Scientific nature of religious studies expertise: possibility and necessity] // novye vyzovy svobody sovesti v sovremennoj Rossii / pod red.E.S.E'lbakyan. M.: Drevo zhizni. - 164 (in Russian)
Gerasimenko, Yu. V., & Vavrux, V.V. (2014). Religiovedcheskaya e'kspertiza: problemy i puti ix resheniya [Religious studies expertise of the problem and ways to solve them] // Nauchnyj vestnik Omskoj akademii MVD Rossii № 4 (55), -75 (in Russian)
Hartikainen E.I. (2019) Candomblé and the Academic’s Tools: Religious Expertise and the Binds of Recognition in Brazil. American Anthropologist, 121(4), -971 (in English)
Myrzaev B.A. (2016) Dіntanu saraptamasy zhat ideologiyalardyn aldyn alu sүzgіsі retіnde [Expertise in religious studies as a filter to prevent foreign ideologies]. - URL:https://www.inform.kz/kz/dintanu-saraptamasy-zhat-ideologiyalardyn-aldyn-alu-suzgisi-retinde_a2928426 (date of the application: 5.05.2023) (in Kazakh)
Ozhegov S.I. (2018) Tolkovyj slovar' russkogo yazyka [Explanatory dictionary of the Russian language]. Pod redakciej prof. L.I.Skvorcova. – 28-oe izdanie. – M.: «OOO «Izdatel'stvo Mir i Obrazovanie», – 1376 (in Russian)
Pchelincev A.V. (2009) E'kspertiza po «bozhestvennym delam»: inkvizaciya ili garantiya svobody religii [Expertise in "God's Affairs": Inquisition or Guarantee of Freedom of Religion] // Religiya i pravo. №3. - 64 (in Russian)
Petrova K.Y.&Orlov M.O. (2017) Religiovedcheskaya e'kspertiza: tipologiya, metodologiya, problemy [Religious expert evalution: typology, methodology, problems] / Aspirantskij vestnik Povolzh'ya - 84 (in Russian)
Poling D.A. & Evans E.M. (2004). Religious belief, scientific expertise, and folk ecology. In Journal of Cognition and Culture (Vol. 4, Issues 3-4) - 774 (in English)
Razuvaev A.A. (2006) E'kspertiza kak sredstvo povysheniya e'ffektivnosti processa pravorealizacii (voprosy teorii i praktiki) [Expertise as a means of increasing the efficiency of the law enforcement process (questions of theory and practice)] avtoref.dis.kand.yurid.nauk. Saratov, -229 (in Russian)
Rossinskaya E.R. (2005) Sudebnaya e'kspertiza v grazhdanskom, arbitrazhnom, administrativnom i ugolovnom processe [Forensic expertise in civil, arbitration, administrative and criminal proceedings]. M.: Norma, - 656 (in Russian)
Souza, A.L.&Legare, C.H. (2011). The role of testimony in the evaluation of religious expertise. Religion, Brain and Behavior, 1(2), -167. (in English)
Tulemetova G. (2022). Voprosy formirovaniya ponyatijnogo apparata religiovedcheskoj e'kspertizy [Issues of Formation of the Conceptual Apparatus of Religious Studies Expertise]. Oriental studies, №3, - 192 (in Russian)
US Embassy and consulate in Kazakhstan [Homepage]. (2023) – URL: https://kz.usembassy.gov/ru/ru-2021-report-on-international-religious-freedom-kazakhstan-2/ (date of the application: 25.05.2023) (in Russian)
Web site of the Committee on Religious Affairs of the Ministry of information and social development of the Republic of Kazakhstan. (2023) – URL: https://www.gov.kz/memleket/entities/din/activities/879?lang=kk&parentId=141 (date of the application: 15.05.2023ж.) (in Kazakh)
Zabiyako A.P. (2019) Religiovedenie kak strogaya nauka [Religious science as a rigorous science], Filosofiya, Religiya, Nauka №3 (11), - 225 (in Russian)
Zagrebina I.V., Pchelincev A.V., E'lbakyan E.S. (2017) Religiovedcheskaya e'kspertiza [Religious expertise]. Uchebnik dlya bakalavriata i magistratury, Moskva. - 449 (in Russian)
Zagrebina I.V., Pchelincev A.V., E'lbakyan E.S. (2021) Practika religiovedcheskoy e'kspertizi [The practice of religious studies expertise] Moskva. - 453 (in Russian)
